🔗 Share this article

“They tried to murder us. They did not succeed. Let’s dine,” commented a local councillor.

This long-standing Jewish adage feels especially pertinent in Greater Manchester in the face of contemporary threats.

For the councillor, the good-humoured statement captures the resilient nature that characterises his Orthodox Jewish neighbourhood.

This dynamic neighbourhood was identified by an extremist undercover group, whose plot to “murder as many Jews as possible” in a violent gun assault was thwarted. Two suspects were convicted this week on terrorism crimes.

Neighbourhood Unity and Daily Challenges

In the words of the councillor, the disrupted plot has not weakened the neighbourhood’s commitment to coexist with its wider community. “My business partner is a practising Muslim and we get on great,” said the father of nine. “You find good and bad in any society. Most just want to live in harmony.”

The individuals saw the Hebrew community solely through the distorted view of hatred.

They showed no interest in the wide-ranging lifestyles, financial situations, religious practice and opinions within the city’s Jewish communities, nor in the pressing social concerns like poverty that impact many British areas.

A local leader runs a family support centre that aids hundreds of families, including large strictly observant families and some Muslim women. The hub offers mother and baby groups, clinics, advice services, educational programs, and crucial financial and material support.

“Those looking in assume the main issue is safety – that’s rubbish,” Ciffer Klein said. “Of course we’re sad and we pray, but the women I work with are struggling to manage with daily routines, pressure and large families. We don’t judge.”

“The cost of living – specialist food is very expensive – utility costs, families who can’t afford milk and nappies, housing, benefits issues – that’s what I’m focused on.”

Increased Vigilance and Unbroken Spirit

Despite these pressures, two unifying themes have grown under pressure. One is a noticeable shift “in favour of community solidarity and involvement,” per a major policy research organisation. The other is a atmosphere of vigilance on a scale rare in most UK towns.

“We can respond to an event in two minutes,” said the executive director of a local civilian patrol group that exchanges information with police.

“The mood is certainly anxious,” they added. “There has been a massive increase in reports to our 24-hour hotline about concerning behaviour.”

Nonetheless, Walters stated that the observant communities, among the fastest-growing in Europe, did not live in terror. “We love life,” he said. “And we believe that if we die, we’re going to a better place. We choose not to be afraid.”

Wider Backdrop and Appeals for Measures

Other leading British Jews say that considerably more must be done to confront the danger of Islamist extremism.

While statistics show that cases with clear right-wing extremist ideology outnumbered those linked to Islamist extremism last year, the most serious plans in recent years have been perpetrated by individuals inspired by extremist ideology.

“A major part of our work on the safety side is trying to spot and disrupt malicious reconnaissance of Jewish locations that would precede an attack,” said a policy head from a safety organisation.

They noted a trend of terrorism and anti-Jewish activity originating from areas north of the city, leading to questions about the particular dynamics in that area.

Recent tragic attacks abroad have occurred with Jewish holidays and commemorations, heightening a sense of global anxiety.

Assessment on a Shifting Paradigm

Some figures suggest that a postwar understanding has altered.

“Historically in Britain, there was a kind of view there was a time of acceptance in terms of post-war understanding of what antisemitism is,” said a director for a Jewish leadership body. “In my view that perspective is starting to be seen as overly hopeful.”

They continued, “It’s not that we think this time is any more dangerous than any of those times before, but that there’s no assumption that troubled times won’t return.”

There is acknowledgement of the efforts being done within Islamic communities to dispute radical narratives, though moderate voices can feel drowned out.

Calls have been made for the government to bring forward a new extremism framework, with an emphasis on tackling the doctrinal threat presented by extremism, separate from faith or people.

Resilience and Hope

However, despite the backdrop of security threats, a thread of positive resilience runs through even sombre events.

“In London to mark an solemn date, the discussion included the recent local attack,” a spokesperson recounted. “Spontaneously, at the end, a performer started playing Jewish tunes and people started celebrating. That is the hopeful side.”

“But I would be lying if I said those sober debates about the future of Jewish life in this country haven’t been ongoing.”